表11   VAS网状Meta分析结果   [OR(95%CI)]

杵针

1.65 (0.84,3.24)

电针

0.56 (0.27,1.15)

0.34 (0.17,0.67)

浮针

0.34 (0.12,1.01)

0.21 (0.09,0.48)

0.61 (0.21,1.79)

浮针+电针

0.33 (0.15,0.75)

0.20 (0.09,0.47)

0.59 (0.32,1.08)

0.97 (0.30,3.19)

芒针

1.20 (0.61,2.36)

0.73 (0.36,1.49)

2.14 (1.43,3.19)

3.51 (1.16,10.55)

3.61 (2.31,5.64)

普通针刺

1.35 (0.62,2.96)

0.82 (0.38,1.79)

2.41 (0.95,6.11)

3.95 (1.26,12.41)

4.06 (1.45,11.42)

1.13 (0.44,2.86)

推拿

0.20 (0.07,0.59)

0.12 (0.04,0.37)

0.36 (0.14,0.91)

0.59 (0.15,2.35)

0.61 (0.24,1.57)

0.17 (0.07,0.39)

0.15 (0.04,0.52)

银质针

1.31 (0.43,3.99)

0.79 (0.33,1.92)

2.33 (0.76,7.09)

3.82 (1.13,12.92)

3.93 (1.16,13.34)

1.09 (0.35,3.40)

0.97 (0.30,3.15)

6.46 (1.58,26.48)

圆利针